Monday, November 19, 2012

Stoker and Catholicism


In Bram Stoker’s novel Dracula, the protagonists use a wide range of weapons to fight the vampire menace plaguing London. The weapons range from garlic and rose branches to crucifixes and holy wafers. By giving Catholic artifacts as much power over the undead as superstitious artifacts, Stoker equates Catholicism to superstition. Throughout English history Catholicism and Protestantism have been at odds with each other. Dracula was originally published in 1897, only 68 years after the Roman Catholic Relief Act of 1829, which emancipated Catholics throughout the United Kingdom and repealed laws which required Catholics to swear allegiance to the crown and prevented them from being elected to parliament (Roman Catholic Relief Act 8).

Since the famous split between Catholic Church and England led by King Henry VIII, there has been much tension between Protestants and Catholics within Great Britain. Queen Mary I, daughter of King Henry VIII, was originally removed from the line for the thrown by her brother, King Edward VI, due to her Catholic views; however, she took the thrown after his death. During Mary I’s reign she revived a law making it a crime “to believe in a different religion than the sovereign,” and burned around 300 Protestants in 3 years (Mary I). After the reign of Queen Mary, the Church of England was restored by her successor, Queen Elizabeth I. Along with the revival of the Church of England came “the arrival of Jesuits and Catholic ministers  from  the  European  continent…  coupled  with  a  national  anxiety  and  fear  of continental  Catholicism  and  the  papacy…  the  English  government  [began] persecutions  against Catholics” (Scott 6). Even today, “No Roman Catholic, nor anyone married to a Roman Catholic, [can] hold the English crown” according to the Act of Settlement passed in 1701. The split from the Catholic Church along with the retaliation of Queen Mary I led to distrust and enmity between Catholics and Protestants in England.

Throughout the novel, Stoker dances with the reader on the line between faith and superstition. Before Jonathan Harker leaves the inn for the Borgo Pass and, what is meant to be his final destination, Dracula’s castle, he is begged by the inn keeper’s wife not leave on St. George’s day, and given a crucifix for protection. Harker writes in his journal, “as an English Churchman, I have been taught to regard such things as in some measure idolatrous”, and in the same entry he notes that he is unsure whether his feeling of uneasiness stems from the strange traditions of the village or the crucifix (Stoker 4).  Later in the story, Van Helsing plans to place a rose branch on Dracula’s crate to prevent him from getting out. Similarly, while attempting to slay the vampire who had been Lucy, Van Helsing places clay containing a holy wafer around the door to prevent Lucy from getting into her tomb. In the Catholic faith, it is the believed that bread is turned into the body of Christ through transubstantiation. The rose and the holy wafer that is thought to be the body of Christ both have equal power over the vampires.

The history of Catholics in Great Britain is one full of enmity and persecution. Although the world is a different place today and tolerance is easier to come by, the tradition of distrust and tyranny of the majority can still be seen in England’s Act of Settle. Stoker’s Dracula is another reminder of the attitude towards Catholics that was so prevalent in his time. While Van Helsing discusses the the rose branch, he says “to superstition must we trust at first; it was man’s faith in the early, and it have it’s root in faith still” (Stoker 281). Perhaps Stoker believed that the Catholic ideology was applicable before, but felt that it was time for a more efficient form of Christianity, such as Protestantism.


Stoker, Bram. Dracula. London: Constable & Co., 1897. Print

Act Of Settlement. The Royal Household, 2008/09. Web. 18 November 2012.

Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829. National Archives, n.d. Web. 18 November 2012.

 Mary I. The Royal Household, 2008/09. Web. 18 November 2012.

Scott, Mitchell. “The Marian and Elizabethan Persecutions: How England Was Prepared for Persecution
and Defended From Martyrdom.” Diss. U of Louisville, 2002. Web. 18 November 2012.

10 comments:

  1. Very interesting and well-written blog post. I feel like you made an excellent claim for your paper and included really valuable outside research. I personally did not put together all of the Catholic artifacts until I read this, which makes it a good read. You bring attention to something that may have been overlooked when it was read. I really like how you paraphrase or give the reader a small plot point instead of trying to reach a word quota with a bunch of quotes from the story. Great work Michael!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment. I was on the brink of giving up this thesis and starting completely over because it seemed that all the animosity between Protestants and Catholics was hundreds of years before the book was written, but then I found the Act of Settlement which is still in effect and I got way too excited than I should have while writing a paper. Anyway... I wasn't completely satisfied with the paragraph giving the history between Catholics and Protestants in England. Do you think that its a necessary paragraph or is most of that information common knowledge?

      Delete
    2. Michael I think that paragraph is necessary as many people don't know the complete story to how Catholic and Protestants have been viewed in England. I see where you explain how Stoker might have negative thoughts about Catholicism, but what in the book shows he might have been for Protestantism?

      Delete
    3. I wasn't able to find anything scholarly, but I read on wikipedia that he was an irish protestant. I didn't have time to check out the biography that the wikipedia link sites as their source, but I'm planning to get it from the library before my 5 page paper. But in the book itself, I thought that the part about Jonathan feeling uneasy about the strange superstitions of Transylvania and the crucifix made a pretty good argument for anti Catholicism. I never thought about whether Stoker was for Protestantism or not, but I'll definitely look into adding that to my paper.

      Delete
    4. I agree with Eugenio because a lot of the information about what exactly England did between the Catholics and Protestants isn't exactly common knowledge so I think this is a really interesting idea. The only problem I had was the thesis was a little hard to find and pick up throughout the post but I think once you have all the facts it makes for a very interesting read and more research on Stoker's religion would be really helpful.

      Delete
    5. I'm glad that it added to the paper. I'm going to research his biography for his views on religion and hopefully that will add some reasoning as to why Stoker would be anti catholicism.

      Delete
    6. It is very necessary to include the paragraph about the conflicts between catholics and protistants because not many people our age know much about English history. I myself like to think that I know everything about King Henry VIII and his split with the church. Also, i REALLY liked that you threw that in about Queen Mary I andQueen Elizabeth I that is an imortant point in the fight between catholics and protestants. Stoker went to the university of Dublin which was founded by Queen Elizabeth I.....We know her beliefs. Point idea?

      Delete
  2. Very interesting. I noticed all the religious artifacts in the book, i thought more on the lines that Dracula is an embodiment of the devil and thats why it helps scare off vampires, i really like this idea that the book could have a hidden meaning like the one you pointed out.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! I definitely see the whole Dracula being the embodiment of evil thing, but I thought it'd be interesting to look at it from a different perspective. While reading I noticed that the crucifix and holy wafer were more commonly Catholic symbols than protestants, so I tried to figure out why Stoker would choose Catholic symbols as opposed to any other religious symbols.

      Delete
    2. I too thought that all of the artifacts were to show the embodiment of evil in the novel but i like that you made the connection to religious beliefs in England during this time. Are you catholic? If not i think you could look into catholic relgious services and traditions. using that you could point out the similarities or what is different.

      Delete